From “Bennifer” to Taylor and Burton, 14 Famous Couples Who Gave Love a Second Chance

Bennifer

Jennifer Lopez and Ben Affleck at the 'Gigli' Los Angeles Premiere in 2003. The pair broke up the following year, but have recently appeared to rekindle their romance. Photo: Amy Graves / Contributor via Getty Images

Two marriages, a few broken engagements, 17 years apart and several children later, Jennifer Lopez, 51, and Ben Affleck, 48, have apparently rekindled their romance after breaking off their high-profile engagement in 2004.

‘Bennifer’ originally called it quits after roughly two years of dating (they first met in 2001 while working as on-screen romantic partners filming Gigli) and Lopez later admitted to Maria Shriver that, “It was probably my first big heartbreak.” It’s too soon to tell whether the pairing will fare better this time around than their movie Gigli did (the film hit theatres in 2003 and brandishes a paltry six per cent fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes), but their recent reemergence inspired us to take a look at other couples who’ve given a past love another try — with varying degrees of success.

 

Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton

Famous Couples
Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton on the film set of ‘The Sandpiper’ in 1965. Photo: API/ GAMMA/Gamma-Rapho/Getty Images

 

The emerald-cut standard of glamorous and tempestuous love matches — and re-matches. The Hollywood icon and Welsh thespian famously met when they starred as adversarial lovers filming the epic 1963 film Cleopatra in Rome; at the time, both were married to other people. With paparazzi in hot pursuit of their scandalous affair, in 1964 Burton proposed at Toronto’s King Edward hotel and they tied the knot in Montreal. In his must-read private diaries, published in 2012, Burton chronicles their intense lust and alcohol-fuelled rows and how both took their toll the first time around in spite of abiding love (and many movies together). They divorced in 1974 and remarried in 1975, but only diamonds are forever: they divorced again less than a year later.

 

Dionne Warwick and William Elliott

Famous Couples
Dionne Warwick walks with her husband, actor William Elliott, at the 44th Annual Academy Awards, Dorothy Chandler Pavilion in Los Angeles in 1972. Photo: Fotos International/Getty Images

 

Dionne Warwick married actor and jazz musician William Elliott — twice. The first time they were married in 1966 but divorced the following year before remarrying just a few months later. “I married him and wanted a divorce and married again. Can’t live, can’t live without,” Warwick once explained. The couple had two sons and were together until 1975. Being the main earner is what ultimately put a strain on the marriage, Warwick told the Guardian. “That is very difficult for the male ego.”

 

Paul Simon and Carrie Fisher

Famous Couples
Paul Simon and Carrie Fisher in France in 1983. Photo: Jean-Jacques LAPEYRONNIE/Gamma-Rapho/Getty Images

 

“Every so often you meet a magic person, and every so often, you meet someone from your tribe,” Fisher wrote in her 2008 memoir Wishful Drinking; “which is how I felt when I met Paul Simon.” The actress and bestselling author first dated the folk singer-songwriter before she was famous, in 1977, as she was filming the first Star Wars movie. During that time she was briefly engaged to Dan Aykroyd (who was on SNL at the time). “She had long conversations on the phone in my presence with Paul Simon, with whom she was attempting to reconcile at the time of my relationship with her,” Aykroyd recalled in an interview with People. In all, Simon and Fisher romanced for a dozen years — including being married in 1983 for just under a year, and dating again following their divorce. His song “Hearts and Bones” is about their relationship.

 

Lucille Ball and Desi Arnaz

Famous Couples
Lucille Ball and Desi Arnaz on the set of the TV series ‘I Love Lucy.’ Photo: Mondadori/Getty Images

 

As shooting continues on Aaron Sorkin’s biopic series Being the Ricardos starring Nicole Kidman and Javier Bardem as Lucille Ball and Desi Arnaz, it’s worth remembering that the pioneering sitcom couple once split before they made TV history. In 1944, spurred by Arnaz’s infidelity and drinking, Ball obtained an interlocutory decree. The couple reconciled before the waiting period was final, but eventually divorced for good in 1960. They, however, remained close friends.

 

John Lennon and Yoko Ono

Famous Couples
John Lennon and Yoko Ono pictured in December 1968, a year before their marriage. Photo: Susan Wood/Getty Images

 

After marrying in 1969, the artist and the former Beatle split in 1973 and lived separately for a little over a year as Lennon carried on a relationship with their former assistant, May Pang. Lennon later called that time ‘the lost weekend.’ In her authorized biography, Ono recalls how she went back to Lennon after seeing him perform with Elton John on stage and seeing how lonely he was. Lennon later called that time ‘the lost weekend.’

 

Natalie Wood and Robert Wagner

Famous Couples
Natalie Wood and Robert Wagner visiting Manhattan following their wedding in December 1957. Photo: Bettmann/Contributor/GettyImages

 

Wood began her career as a child star and grew up before our eyes in Rebel Without a Cause and West Side Story. After dating Elvis and Tab Hunter she stepped out with “R.J.,” as the 91-year-old Wagner is known, when she turned 18 in 1956 (Wagner was 26), and they wed a year later. Divorce came in 1962, after which she dated Warren Beatty and married Richard Gregson. When they, too, divorced, she got in touch with Wagner. They remarried and were together almost a decade until her tragic and mysterious 1981 death by drowning off their yacht Splendour in Catalina.

 

Pamela Anderson and Rick Salomon

Famous Couples
Rick Salomon and Pamela Anderson attend the Pamela Anderson Foundation launch co-hosted by Dame Vivienne Westwood in support of Cool Earth at the Cannes Film Festival in May 2014. Photo: David M. Benett/Getty Images for The Pamela Anderson Foundation

 

The Canadian Baywatch star wed her longtime friend, and American poker player, Salomon in 2007 and again in 2014; one marriage was annulled and other lasted only a few months. He still carries a torch, apparently (one endorsed by her adult sons). Hope springs eternal.

 

Marie Osmond and Steve Craig

Famous Couples
Steve Craig and Marie Osmond attend the premiere of Universal Pictures’ ‘Jason Bourne’ at The Colosseum at Caesars Palace in July 2016. Photo: Gabe Ginsberg/FilmMagic

 

The Mormon singer first married pro basketball player Craig in 1982, but they divorced in 1985 after having one child. Nearly 30 years later it was reportedly Craig who helped her cope after the suicide of her son Michael (one of Osmond’s eight children with her second husband). Osmond and Craig remarried in 2011 but only after keeping their rekindled relationship a secret from everyone for two years. Even her children didn’t know. “I didn’t want anybody to get hurt, you know if it didn’t work out. And gosh, it just worked out,” she told Good Morning America.

 

Farrah Fawcett and Ryan O’Neal

Famous Couples
O’Neil and Fawcett were romantically involved for 18 years before their original breakup in 1997, but got back together in 2001. Photo: Hulton-Deutsch Collection/CORBIS/Corbis via Getty Images

 

Although the blond-maned breakout star of Charlie’s Angels and the Love Story star had a son together in 1985, their turbulent 18-year relationship ended in 1997 after she discovered him having an affair. They re-united in 2001 when Fawcett was diagnosed with cancer and remained together until her death (which they chronicled in a raw documentary, Farrah’s Story) in 2009.

 

Frida Kahlo and Diego Rivera

Famous Couples
Diego Rivera and Frida Kahlo, in Mexico City in 1939. Photo: Bettmann/Contributor/GettyImages

 

When teenage Frida Kahlo met Diego Rivera — 20 years her senior — he was already an established artist. They married in 1929 — Kahlo aged 22 and Rivera aged 42 — and her parents dubbed them ‘the elephant and the dove.’ They divorced in 1939, only to reconcile the following year, and the tumultuous relationship of these important Mexican artists is captured in the many artworks they painted of each other during that time. The couple remained together until her death in 1952.

 

William H. Macy and Felicity Huffman

Famous Couples
William H. Macy and Felicity Huffman at California’s Pelican Hill Resort in May 2010. Photo: Jason Merritt/TERM/Staff/GettyImages

 

The actors have been married for 24 years but, prior to that, they dated off and on for 15 years; Macy proposed several times but it wasn’t until after they’d been broken up a few years that he asked again and Huffman accepted. “I was so scared of marriage that I thought I would’ve preferred to step in front of a bus,” Huffman admitted in one interview. They first met in the early 1980s at New York’s Atlantic Theatre Company, “and that’s really at the core of our relationship,” Macy once addedThe Desperate Housewives star recently served a 14-day prison sentence after pleading guilty in the college admissions scandal.

 

Lana Turner and Joseph Crane

Famous Couples
Lana Turner smiles while holding her newborn daughter, Cheryl Crane, next to her second and third husband (she married him twice), Stephen Crane, 1944. Photo: Express/Express/Getty Images

 

After meeting at Hollywood’s famed Mocambo nightclub in 1942, the film noir siren and the restauranteur married twice in rapid succession — mainly because the first marriage wasn’t legal. Crane was still married to his first wife at the time. Neither nuptials lasted.

 

Rosemary Clooney and José Ferrer

Famous Couples
Director Jose Ferrer and singer Rosemary Clooney attend the premiere of ‘Rear Window’ in August 1954 in Los Angeles. Photo: Earl Leaf/Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images

 

The renowned crooner (and beloved aunt to George Clooney) and the Academy Award-winning Puerto Rican movie star wed twice, first after eloping in the early 1950s and again in the 1960s before calling it quits. “There was intense love, but living together was too hard,” son Gabriel, one of their five children, later recalled. “My mother always said my father was a great father and a so-so husband.”

 

The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge

Famous Couples
Prince William, Duke of Cambridge, and Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge, smile following their marriage at Westminster Abbey on April 29, 2011 in London, England. Photo: Chris Jackson/Getty Images

 

Kate Middleton and Prince William met while attending the University of St. Andrews in Scotland and they are rumoured to have been an item before 2004; he later reportedly broke up with her by phone in 2007 (according to the royal biography Battle of Brothers). But as the world knows, they reunited soon after, got engaged in 2010, and have now been married a decade.

RELATED:

Older Woman, Younger Man: Olivia Wilde, Harry Styles and the Women Redefining May-December Romances