Holiday Shopping: The Big Deal
The big deal – bargains on iPads and smart TVs — isn’t the only reason we make a big deal out of Black Friday and Cyber Monday.
“It’s entertainment,” says Judy Zaichkowsky, marketing professor at Simon Fraser University.
“Retail theater,” declares the Wall Street Journal.
“A tradition, a collective ritual, like watching the Grey Cup or Stanley Cup or Superbowl,” suggests Russell Belk, marketing professor at York University’s Schulich School of Business.
Behind the “collective frenzy,” says Belk, are psychological motives as well as financial ones.
“Some people no matter what their age love a bargain,” says Zaichowsky. “You think you’re smart. You’ve beat the other guy by getting it for less. It’s self-affirming.”
She also suggests Black Friday became an event in the U.S. because Thanksgiving is the biggest holiday of the year — a huge family event.
By the time Friday comes, people want to get away from the relatives. (Maybe Boxing Day is our Black Friday for the same reason.)
But why do otherwise sane people fight over goods that are available, albeit at a somewhat higher cost, other days?
“Bargain hunting can be dysfunctional,” says Belk. “In the excitement, reasonable caution is often thrown to the wind.”
Besides, except for a few loss leaders in limited quantities, the bargains are mostly “a carefully engineered illusion,” declares the Wall Street Journal.
Zaichkowsky says stores lure shoppers with advertised loss leaders on Black Friday, then entice them to buy full-price or near full price goods.
“Americans are extremely good at esthetics and display,” she says, “We’re all attracted to nice things. You want to touch them. Once you touch them, they’re yours.”
She cautions, “There’s so much impulse at the point of sale.”
Her advice for Black Friday or bargain shopping: